Paramedic Papers

Home Trauma Prehospital trauma scores poorly predict secondary transfer

Trauma

Prehospital trauma scores poorly predict secondary transfer

Prehospital Trauma Scoring Systems for Discriminating Recorded Secondary Transfer in Multiply Injured Patients: A Comparative Study with Machine Learning
Journal of Clinical Medicine · 2026-11-12 · Added 17 November 2026

A Turkish EMS record review of 1,194 multiply injured patients compared eight prehospital trauma scores for predicting secondary interhospital transfer, finding CRAMS performed best but only modestly (AUC 0.676), while a random forest model reached AUC 0.836.

Study type
Cohort
Design
Retrospective cohort with ROC comparison of eight trauma scores and machine learning
Participants
1,194 multiply injured patients (47% secondarily transferred)
Main finding
CRAMS had the highest score discrimination (AUC 0.676); paediatric age (OR 4.46), elderly age (OR 2.44) and thoracic injury (OR 1.68) were independently associated with transfer; random forest AUC 0.836 versus 0.765 for logistic regression, with calibration compressed toward average risk
Caveat
Single-province EMS records, weak score discrimination, and a model needing recalibration and external validation
Bottom line
Hypothesis-generating

Why it matters in Australia (Medium relevance). Trauma destination and transfer decisions are made by crews everywhere, but the scores discriminated weakly and the better-performing machine-learning model is unvalidated.

Learning goal

Strengthen my judgement on when a multiply injured patient will need secondary interhospital transfer.

Open in dashboard Read the paper (DOI)

More

Related papers on Trauma